Simmons vs. Ingram: The Case for the #1 Pick



When commissioner Adam Silver steps up to the podium and announces who the 76ers will be picking with the No. 1 overall pick in the 2016 NBA Draft, there are two very intriguing prospects that both have an equal chance of hearing their name called. These two prospects, Ben Simmons and Brandon Ingram, both present elite talent and superstar potential. They excel both offensively and defensively, and are already drawing very flattering comparisons, with Simmons being labeled “the next Lebron James” and Ingram “the next Kevin Durant.” Philadelphia will definitely have a tough decision to make, so I’m going to try and make it for them by comparing the two and predicting who I would draft if I were 76ers general manager Bryan Colangelo.

When it comes to pure talent, both of these prospects have loads of it bleeding through their veins. They are two of the most talented prospects in recent memory and both should have very successful NBA careers. With Simmons, the 6’10” forward from LSU, he first and foremost has an uncanny ability to make plays and become a prominent leader right off the bat. He has great strength for his position and uses that strength to win one-on-one battles and become the playmaker he is. Simmons is very explosive, especially when it comes to driving down the court. He uses his top-notch speed to get to the basket and find some form of success, whether it’s scoring, getting fouled, or finding an open teammate. When it comes to passing, he is also extraordinary. He has tremendous court vision and elite abilities as a passer, often slinging beautiful passes to open teammates. Simmons also has very nice body control which helps him on both phases of the game. On offense he uses his body control and creativity to finish around the rim and get good shots, while on defense his body control plays a huge part for getting rebounds and staying with opposing players. Simmons also was very successful in the post, where he was very crafty and could finish with either hand. He can do it all it seems, as Simmons generated 19.2 PPG, 11.8 RPG, and 4.8 APG, 0.8 BPG, and 2.0 SPG. This is a prospect who will amaze scouts with his talent, but he certainly has some glaring weaknesses that could become major red flags in the NBA.

The first weakness that stands out from Simmons’ play is his shooting ability. He is not a successful shooter, especially from behind the arc. He doesn’t trust his jump shot and is often reluctant to shoot the ball over the course of a game. Defenders see this and tend to play off a little with the intention to force him to shoot the ball. From behind the three-point line, which is widely regarded as his biggest weakness, Simmons is awful. He put up only three three-point shots while only making one of them. states that over the course of 74 games dating back to 2012, Simmons is 12/50 from the three-point line, or 24 percent. He also could improve his free throw shooting, as he often gets fouled a lot and only shot 67 percent from the line. Overall, Simmons needs to greatly improve his overall shooting if he wants to become a complete offensive player. Another glaring weakness is his intensity and attitude on the defensive side of the ball. Unlike offense, Simmons is very lazy when he is on defense and often shies away from contact with opposing players. His competitiveness as a whole gets called into question and he will definitely need to fix that when he reaches the NBA level. The good news is that he is capable of fixing these problems, the bad news is that if he doesn’t fix them and continues his lazy defensive play in the pros, he will not have nearly as much success and he is capable of having.

Brandon Ingram, the 6’9″ forward from Duke, in my opinion is the more complete prospect. He immediately catches the eyes of scouts with his remarkable length and jaw-dropping 7’3″ wingspan. Ingram’s length allows him to do things that other players simply just can’t do. He displays a great strides down the court and has an impressive display of moves he uses to make plays happen. He is very good at creating his own shot and getting to the basket, as he seems to have the ability to almost glide all throughout the court due to his long legs. He is a very good ball-handler for his size with great footwork and great control of his length when attacking opposing defenders. Unlike Simmons, Ingram is a great shooter from all levels. He has a beautiful jump shot, with a quick release and fluid mechanics. He was very consistent with it and he also displayed a very nice three-point shot, hitting 41 percent of his attempts. On defense, Ingram was a lot better than most people originally thought. He once again uses his length to his advantage in this phase of the game, contesting and blocking a good amount of shots. He was surprisingly effective when going up against guards, being able to stride with them and stay in front of them despite them being faster and quicker. Ingram is also the youngest prospect in this draft class at 18 years old, and he still is growing into his body which is a scary thing to think about. Ingram has a no-nonsense attitude and has been highly praised for his elite work ethic and competitiveness.

Ingram still has a few weaknesses, though. The most obvious one is his very skinny frame. He is very skinny and weighs only 196 lbs. He needs to work hard in the NBA to gain more weight so that he can be more effective and explosive against bigger competitors. His frame can cause him to struggle on offense when it comes to finishing around the basket and posting up, and also on defense when it comes to getting pushed around in the paint and grabbing rebounds. All of this should continue to improve as he gets stronger, and with his determination there should be no reason to worry. Like Simmons, Ingram can improve at free-throw shooting, as he converted only 68 percent of his free throws. Ingram also struggles on defense despite his decent play. He often gets caught up in screens and overall began to look lost sometimes, which resulted in foul trouble. The unique thing about Ingram is that basically all of his weaknesses can start to become less problematic as he gains more weight. He is extremely advanced for his age and very highly skilled.

When it comes to how each player would fit in Philadelphia, both players would fill a similar role. Simmons would become an instant leader of that young team, providing a offensive spark that they so desperately needed. He can provide that talented group of big men somebody to get them the ball and create plays for them. He also would be a guy that can quickly get double-teamed, providing them more opportunities to get the ball and receive some action. Simmons is the kind of player that can make up for the lack of a point guard and bring this team into the playoff conversation instantly. Ingram would be a similar type of player for them, providing an electrifying scorer and an intimidating mismatch due to his length. Ingram wouldn’t be as much of a vocal leader, but he would certainly be a guy the team gravitates to. He wouldn’t be as much of a defensive presence but he would definitely be an intimidating presence. Both of these players can be future superstars and would help this 76ers team immensely.

My selection: Brandon Ingram

No hard feelings to Ben Simmons, but I would draft Ingram if I were the 76ers. Ingram just has a better all around game and will get better and better as his career progresses. Yes Ingram is very skinny, so is Kevin Durant. I wouldn’t be worried about that at all and I wouldn’t make that a factor in my decision whatsoever. The negative reviews about Simmons competitiveness would worry me a lot more. His lack of shooting ability is also cause for major concern, especailly in today’s NBA where shooting is everything. The 76ers in my opinion can’t afford to take a player who struggles shooting the ball since they lack a pure scorer, and Ingram fits that bill. I also can’t see them taking a chance on a guy who might not give it his all 100 percent of the time, cause they can’t afford to take one of those guys either. You also have to think about how even with Simmons leading the pact at LSU, he wasn’t able to take them to the tournament even though it has to due in large part to the lack of talent around him. I mean even he is partly to blame for their below average season. Simmons may very well end up proving me wrong and being a top player in this league, and I wouldn’t be suprised. He has loads of talent and already is more physcially advanced than Ingram by a mile. But Ingram is just too special in my opinion to pass up. Combine his talent on both ends of the floor with his age, his length, and his work ethic, and there is no reason to believe he can’t eventually become the top player in this league. It will no doubt be a very tough decision come draft night, but I would go with Brandon Ingram as the No. 1 overall pick in the 2016 NBA draft.



Author: Alex LaRocca

Just a teenager from Jersey who loves to talk about sports

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s